December 13, 2009

Modernist Primitivism and Post-Colonial thought in the Post-modern Age

Since the inception of modernist art, Africa has been a source of inspiration for artists attempting to deviate from traditional forms of classical Western art. However, the relationship between Western modernist artists and African art is fraught with issues that stem from the colonialist era, and continue to inform the art historical dialogue of African art in the West in the post-modern age. From the two sources of Kwame Appiah’s scholarly article “Is the Post- in Post-modernism the Post- in Postcolonial?” and the insightful documentary titled “African Art”, this paper will attempt to apply theories of modernist primitivism to post-colonialism in the post-modern art world, citing specific examples of art, and also address overarching questions of ideology and cultural superiority that stem from these sources and the trajectory of Western appropriation of African art.

To understand the deeply ingrained presence of primitivism in modern art and its subsequent continuation as a complex issue in post-modernist art of the post-colonial era, it is necessary to understand the origins of African influence on Western modernism. The notion of a Primitivist view of Africa in Western thought stems from the colonial era, when European nations dominated African and Eastern cultures politically, and ideologically categorized these cultures as inferior. To quote scholars Mark Antliff and Patricia Leighten on the term, “The relation is one of contrast, of binary opposition to the ‘civilized’…Within the context of modernism, ‘primitivism’ is an act on the part of artists and writers seeking to celebrate features of the art and culture of peoples deemed ‘primitive’ and to appropriate their supposed simplicity and authenticity to the project of transforming Western art.”[1] This ideology of the West as a dominant and superior culture, manifested itself in several ways, especially in the advent of modernist painting. Because the cultures of Africa were considered “primitive,” the arts of those cultures acted as a fantasy in the Western imagination. Pablo Picasso’s reaction to these “curios” he encountered in the early 20th century illuminated the Orientalist relationship between the West and Africa during this time. In his imagination, African art was made from a savage culture, and this gave it an inherent truth or simplicity. Picasso even went so far as to claim the African masks he saw had magical powers in their detachment from “civilized” Western culture, and believed that in its origin from a “less developed” culture, African art could help the Western artist to access some deeper and truer part of his spirit. It is this idea of African art as “exotica” from a civilization developmentally behind the West and the view of these art objects as mysterious and dark “fetishes” that one can see the superior position the Western modernist artist took as they essentialized African culture.

“Demoiselles D’Avignon” shows Picasso’s interpretation of the “primitive” female, showing the racial “other” as prostitutes, brazenly taunting the viewer with their overt sexuality. The females are rendered rather grotesquely, and the manner in which Picasso renders them as “savage” is via the utilization of the African mask, which perpetuates the stereotypical view of the women of other cultures as, “impure, degenerate, and corrupting”.[2] Much more could be said on the anxieties about “primitive” cultures that are expressed in this painting, but it is more productive to this argument to investigate the ways in which Picasso’s modernist “primitivism” has persisted and progressed in the development of a Western understanding (or misunderstanding) of African art in the post-modern age, and how that ideology is also beginning to be questioned and transformed. The essentializing view of modernist “primitivism” has persisted in post-modern age of art exhibitions, but in slightly different ways. While African art is still misunderstood and essentialized, it is now done so with less overt racism, and more through the persisting opinion of Western art critics and curators of the superiority of the artistic traditions of the West, and their inability to situate Western culture as the “other” and truly understand and represent the cultural context from which an African art object came. The film “African Art” investigates these issues in the context of the 1985 MOMA exhibition titled “ ‘Primitivism’ in 20th Century Art: Affinity of the Tribal and the Modern,” a show which became a critical point for discourse regarding the position of African art in the Western art world. Though the show attempted to equalize the two artistic traditions, the implicit assumption of Western superiority was still very much present, mainly in the decontextualization of the African art objects. The example of a carved antelope headdress from a small Mali village is cited as emblematic of the problems with the “Affinity” show. The object was placed in the traditional Western setting, behind glass and softly lit, but this context could not be further from the intention of the carvers from this village, where the headdress has a specific and defined social function and rich cultural heritage. To include it in this show, in this way, is not only presenting the African art as irrelevant aside from its ability to inspire the superior Western artist, but also misrepresents and ignores the meaning of it from the original context. The presentation of this piece speaks to the common occurrence in Western thought to disregard art from other cultures except for their aesthetic nature, which is to miss the significance of that art in its original country of origin, and to essentialize their cultural product to whatever meaning the Westerner can find visually, not anthropologically.

Kwame Anthony Appiah takes an exhibition from a few years later, in 1987, which was titled “Perspectives: Angles on African Art”, and held at the Center for African Art in New York as a starting point for his argument regarding the enduring presence of a Western superiority towards African artists and art objects. Appiah uses one specific piece from this show to prove his theory that post-colonialism does not negate colonialist ideologies in the same manner post-modernism negated tenets of modernist art that artists found obsolescent in the contemporary world. A small wooden sculpture is described in the exhibition catalog as “neo-traditional,” in its depiction of Western clothing and technology, but has nothing to do with post-modernism as it is understood by the rest of the art world. Appiah negates Max Weber’s theory that humanity has progressed to an era of “rational modernism” and instead acknowledges the contradictions inherent in this representation. He argues that “neo-traditional” simply means post-colonial art, created by the racial ‘other’ for Western consumption, and that this sculpture in many ways perpetuates colonialist thought.

There are many lingering questions about the state of post-colonial ideology in the West’s understanding of African art. Some African cultures chosen for exhibition in these shows do not even have a word for “art” as the West knows it, which is illuminating of the Western tendency to use the “other” as a way to define our own culture. Any changes in cultural perception of African art, and the attempt to rectify the Western history of colonialism is still using the subject as a way to affirm a progression to Weber’s “rational modernism,” and is not about African art itself.[3] In reality, there are too many variables to define another culture outside of their original context, and even today the understanding of African art has fallen into the dualism of either ethnocentric misunderstanding or exoticising primitivism. Unless the art world can place the West as the “other” and truly begin to understand the cultural context from which these art objects came, we will fall into the trap of perpetuating colonial ideology, even in the post-modern era.

[1] Mark Antliff and Patricia Leighton, “Primitive,” from Critical Terms for Art History, Nelson and Schiff, Eds., Chicago (1996): 170.
[2] Anna C. Chave, “New Encounters with Les Demoiselles D’Avignon: Gender, Race, and the Origins of Cubism,” Art Bulletin (December 1994): 606.
[3] Kwame Anthony Appiah, “Is the Post- in Post-modernism the Post- in Postcolonial?,” Critical Inquiry, Vol. 17, No. 2 (Winter, 1991): 343-344.

December 02, 2009

Holly Andres at Robert Koch Gallery

Review IV.

This past break I had the pleasure of visiting Robert Koch Gallery in San Francisco. The gallery was exhibiting a solo show of the photography of Holly Andres titled Holly Andres: Sparrow Lane. This collection of photography embodies the return to the personal and the vague expression of memory prominent in contemporary post-modern art. Ambiguity and intrigue are essential to this body of work.
Andres presents a series of color photographs, chronicling mysterious an enchanting moments of female adolescence. For each photo, the artist has composed an extravagant and meticulously detailed set for the captured scene. This, along with the bright colors and curious scenarios give a sense of other worldliness. In this series Andres is both presenting the viewer with something sincerely familiar about the childhood experience, while imbuing the represented memory with aspects of the supernatural.
Some highlights from her exhibition:
















One of my favorite photographs was humorously titled "The Lost Bird", and the scene seems reminiscent of a movie still. The figure at the bottom of the picture giving the piece a sense of drama of the hunt, while the girls who illogically look behind a picture frame make the photo playful as well as surreal.
Many of the photographs were glimpses onto personal and partial memories of the artist, presented to the viewer with dreamlike lighting, presumably how one remembers defining moments from their youth. One shows a little girl hanging a locket from a bird's nest, a special hiding spot or meeting place perhaps. Her gaze at something in the sky and out of frame endows the scene with an eerie quality that is a defining aspect of this artist's work.
Darker memories also prevail in this series, one fantastic photo titled "The Dark Portal" shows a little girl at the door of a small crawl space, golden locks of hair litter the hallways behind her as two older girls crawl up into the attic. The events of the scene are ambiguous, but the locks of hair belong to someone, and one can imagine the trauma felt by the little girl as she goes to her hiding place. I liked that Andres inserts traces of the magical or supernatural in these scenes, to further their ambiguity but also express the intangibility of events that occur in our youth.

Pictures of the young women coming upon destroyed objects (a pink armchair lying out on the road, a ripped pillow, a broken jug of milk on the front porch) encouraged a reading of a somewhat troubled adolescence, where these damaged pieces of the home cannot quite be comprehended yet in the colorful haze of childhood. These pieces were the most engaging, as Andres is so successful at conveying suspense and ominousness in her work. The artist does a wonderful job of expressing the innocence of youth, while maintaining a surreal grasp on more sinister themes. I think this is what makes her work both immediately accessible and enjoyable, while simultaneously being unsettling and thought-provoking when one investigates the pictures further.

Another prominent theme in this series is the coming-of -age story of the female adolescent. Pictures that dealt with this were charming depictions of the young subjects discovering the magical and unknown properties of adult life while snooping through their mother's things and belongings (though it would be prudent to say that it does not matter the relationships or details of the scene, because Andres relates images outside of specific time and place, and is more interested in conveying an essence of a memory, or a moment of powerful feeling that has staying power from childhood). "The Red Purse" shows a little girl opening up a ladies' handbag to a bright and glowing light that illuminates her face in the dark bedroom. I thought this was a wonderful way to show the excitement and wonder of a child discovering some aspect of adult life. However in this picture and the rest there is also an ominous feeling, that what they find is not nessecarily positive. She uses the vivid olor and surreal lighting as a way to convey this sense of dreamlike memory, but it also succeeds in communicating the mystery and subsequent sinister nature of some childhood discoveries. ("The DIscarded Photo" below, is a good example of this ominous feeling).






























The ambiguity of these photographs enhances their power, as the viewer can transfer onto them their own experiences whether with violence and arguments, coming of age memories, or glimpses back to the small rituals and oddities everyone experiences as a child. Andres is thus successful in combining the familiar and known with the forgotten and magical.

November 24, 2009

Thoughts on Mapplethorpe and Art after Post-modernism


Obviously the work of Robert Mapplethorpe has been highly controversial in the past, and many investigations into meaning and presentation have been written by other scholars. I just had some thoughts about his work from what we discussed as a class.

Aside from the Jesse Helms obscenity objection, which is absurd and impinging upon artistic freedom of expression, it was said in class that some people object to Mapplethorpe's art photography style. In a sense, that the artist is showing us an aesthetic without interfering, a presentation without re-presentation. This is the same critique post-modernist theorists gave to Avedon, that he doesn't intervene with his presentations of characters and doesn't draw attention to the medium of photography itself as an indexical form.

However, I think that Mapplethorpe's work should be given more credit in the context of post-modern theory. What if, instead of reading his aestheticized black body as a presentation of homosexual desire and the ideal form, we read it as an exposee of the stereotypical and racist fetishization of black men?
I think the photograph of the man exposing himself while dressed in an expensive suit is the best example of this idea, perhaps commenting on the persistence of racism and stereotypes though some say our society has moved past them.
I wonder if Mapplethorpe was a black artist himself, criticism of his work would differ. If perhaps we would see his photographs as a continuation of Cindy Sherman's work, exposing the viewer's desires and expectations of an identity: in this case black men instead of women. Is it their position as men, presented in a way that highlights their masculinity that prevents this reading? I would disagree, because I think his photographs are presenting a queered masculinity in a lot of ways.
If Barbara Kruger gendered her audience, perhaps Mapplethorpe racializes us? Does he determine our sexual orientation? The playful nature of Kruger and Sherman of the 1980's is gone, the AIDS epidemic influencing much of the work during this period, and instead we are left with this extension of post-modernism that has many complex facets.

We talked in class about art after post-modernism being vague, personal, and making the viewer uncomfortable. Artists like Mapplethorpe, Kara Walker, and Robert Gober all exemplify this: creating art that somehow engages with important social issues like racism while leaving it up to the audience to glean the meaning. If we interpret Mapplethorpe as not intervening with the presentation enough, is he not right in step with his fellow generation of artists?

November 15, 2009

"When Smoking Was Cool" at Black Maria Gallery (Review III)



Black Maria Gallery, located in Atwater Village, caters to the underground art scene, attempting to show artists that engage with social and political issues through the "low-brow, avant-garde, or subversive". Their current exhibition "When Smoking Was Cool" features artists whose work itself seems "cool", utilizing strategies that are considered to exist outside of the elitist art world's value system.
The show is a charming, tongue-in-cheek commentary about our culture's zealous knee-jerk reaction to the evils of smoking. The catalog offers artist's statements about the taxation of tobacco and alcohol products over other societal ills, and one gets the sense of a community of artists within this gallery structure that want to make a political point with their work, mocking mainstream culture with their underground sensibility.
Artist Anthony Ausgang has two works in this show, both featuring his signature animated style. Famous for fiercely opposing what he calls "art bureaucracy", Ausgang's work seems ardently satirical even at first glance, denying any high-minded or theoretical interpretation. Borrowing from mid-century cartoons, he figures retro cats, down and out but smiling, picking at trashed cigarettes on the street.
"The Butt Picker" (left) besides having a hilarious title, was provocative, parodying the opinion high society may have of the poor, the homeless, and the smoker. The retro feel to this piece forces the viewer to see the depiction as antiquated, thus Ausgang succeeds in pointing out the flaws and arbitrariness of some societal views with his ironic caricature.

Another piece successful in poking fun at upper-crust society is by the artist Candy and titled "Gold Digger". The piece is acrylic on wood, and uses an animation aesthetic as well, perhaps as a way of distancing the work from "high art" as Ausgang has done. Candy also creates a caricature, of a rich gold-digging woman, exuding sexuality and greed, fiercely chomping down upon a cigarette. The result is an amusing pastiche on the leisure-class and a different riff on "smoker culture".

Paul Chatem shows two works, combines of wood and painted, working gears. He creates a space of industrial hell, where the working class are portrayed as living in the bowels of some terrible, fantasy factory with roots in the industrial revolution. One can see some influence from animation in his works as well, the pop and surrealist aesthetic of the "underground" art scene prevalent in most works in this show.

Works by Sarah Stephens, painted on matchbooks and cigarette boxes, evoke a yearning for a simpler time. The color palette, compositions, and technique of cutting out and color blocking certain parts of a landscape in these small works reminded me a lot of Ed Ruscha and I wonder if her vision of Los Angeles relics from the 50's and 60's is a bit derivative of some of his work. Nonetheless, the works are appealing and match with the show's theme of transporting the viewer to the past, though to different ends for each piece.
Artists Christine Karas, Stacy Lande, Brett Manning and Harry Sudman all showed portraits of characters that are smoking, or are somehow representative of a counter-cultural movement, whether it be prostitutes or musicians. Brett Manning's piece was a caricature of a french woman, which had very beautiful pencil-work and a personal quality about it.

Shark Toof is the artist that exhibited the majority of works in the "When Smoking Was Cool" show. His style combines a pop aesthetic, with the design elements of graffiti art, which is what he is best known for. The works he showed here were indicative of urban Los Angeles street art and the playfulness often found in street art...these pieces were the highlight of the visit. First, a series of fantasy portraits of celebrities smoking embody the disdain of this underground art movement for popular culture icons, or at least Shark Toof's willingness to create a joke at their expense. He reprises the visages of Barack Obama, Kanye West, Taylor Swift, and Michael Jackson as characters from a cheesy horror movie from the 1950's. My favorite is "Kanye West" dressed as a mummy, with a mouthful of lit cigarettes (below with "Barack Obama").

These certainly fit in with the theme of the caricature in the show, and in dismantling iconography of contemporary popular culture.
The other pieces he shows were more indicative of his street and graffiti art style. "Smoke Now Cry Later" is a mixed media piece that looks like an urban wall scene, covered in posters and graffiti. Shark Toof's signature shark figure and images of cigarettes are pasted upon blurry female faces. Broken and twisted butts spell out the title, and two burning cigarettes spell out the iconic L.A. sign in the bottom right corner. This piece embodies the gritty and gutsy nature of street art within the space of the gallery. The message and title of the piece is emblematic of the fearless attitude of this artistic sub-culture, living in the moment and challenging established notions of artistic value and pedigree.

November 02, 2009

Juxtapoz, Hi-Fructose and the "Hip" Aesthetic



I don't know if anyone else reads these magazines, but I was perusing a copy of my room mate's Juxtapoz subscription the other day and it struck me that everything I see in that magazine, as well as Hi-Fructose, and much of the art in galleries around Los Angeles has a very similar aesthetic.
I think it is best described by a hyper-realistic, fantasy. Many of the works seem to be influenced by surrealist notions of strangeness and images of dreams. Another noticeable aspect in this art seems to be its appropriation of child-like imagery. Much of the work I see in Juxtapoz plays off the idea of toys, dolls, cuteness, or imagination- but retools those images to become a sort of hallucination, often strange and disturbing. The images to the left and bottom are by Los Angeles artist Mark Ryden.
















Here is another example of a painting by Ron English and a sculpture by Eric Althin that stays true to this aesthetic in a different medium.


I wonder if the hyper-realism so prevalent in some of these artists has to do with new computer technology, as I see increasingly more of them turning to digital imaging to either create, or inspire their works.







Many of these artists are also interesting in the sort of hip, underground, street scene of Los Angeles and other big cities. I see a lot of influence from that world, from skateboarding and graffiti art.





I know there is a market for this type of work, with hip stores like Giant Robot popping up all over the place. Just the other weekend I went into a gallery downtown that doubled as a skate shop/ tattoo parlor, and believe it or not it was crowded. Artists popular in these magazines also have no qualms about slapping their work on T-shirt or sneakers, or churning out some cute key chains or stuffed animals. In terms of the consumerism and "cute", yet hip aesthetic, Takashi Murakami could be included in this group of artists, though he more than any other has experienced wild success.

Does this aesthetic have any place in the art historical trajectory of post-modernism and beyond? I do not know if critics take this type of work seriously, or if as of yet it has remained ensconced in a counter-culture commercialism.

October 20, 2009

Critique II

Highlights from Invisible Body, Conspicuous Mind

The Luckman Gallery at Cal State University Los Angeles is holding an exhibition of artwork by Romanian artists that deals with the state of the isolated citizen in a post-communist bloc country. However, much of the work references struggles with personal identity within the institution of society and lends itself to interpretations not exclusive to the Romanian experience, but instead raises issues relevant to a broader contemporary audience.


This opening piece by Lia Perjovschi confronts the viewer the moment one walks into the space. An ink on vinyl wall installation, her piece employs a textual diagram exploring the connections between language, politics, and the ways in which identity is constructed. The term "subject" is at the center of the piece, and in a rather fascinating strategy of disseminating information, Perjovschi scrawls the issues relating to each peripheral buzz word (environment, democracy, free will, etc.) to construct a literal and semantic map of the ways in which one can define an identity.













Dan Perjovschi, who is best known for his performances in which he allows museum-goers to watch him draw directly on the walls of an exhibition space, in this show is exhibiting 30 panels of more subtle, framed drawings that seem to investigate the aloneness and alienation of the contemporary citizen. These small cartoonish drawings of faces within a grid, some squares left conspicuously empty, are evocative of feelings of isolation within a crowd. Though surrounded by other faces, and panels of faces, the people in his small drawings are drawn with a sense of anguish and angst, as conveyed by the jerky scribbled lines. Perjovschi's installation very successfully visually represents the state of Romanian society, wherein the residual effects of surveillance and military occupation of the repressive Communist era have created a fragmented and distrusting society.

The show featured several photographs and video installations, some more engaging and relevant to the central theme of the exhibition than others. A photograph by Ciprian Muresan titled "Leap Into the Void, After Three Seconds" is one of these pieces, and was even chosen as the publicity image for the exhibition, shown on the brochure and website. A reference to the iconic picture by Yves Klein that shows a man flinging himself off of a building, Muresan's photograph is a rather clever commentary on post-modern art, as well as the futility of some aspects of modern life. By showing the end result of Klein's neo-Dada ambition as a man fallen face-first into pavement, Muresan is able to express the disappointment of the post-modern times that art, as well as civilization, has not advanced very far. The presence of another figure turning his back on the fallen man also speaks to the "invisible body' theme of the exhibition and apathy of contemporary society. This multi-faceted image is an excellent example of the capabilities of appropriation in the medium of digital photography to create a critically engaged post-modernist work of art.

Another shining example of photography in this show was Alexandra Croitoru's two pictures shown side by side and titled "ROM_". The photographer is the subject, and she shows herself in a bikini, imitating a vacation photo by posing in front of an idyllic blue boy of water. At odds with this faux-tourist image is the ski mask she wears in Romanian colors in both photos. By utilizing visual conventions familiar to the viewer, Croitoru brings all the association one has with a vacation photo, or an almost nude woman, or the criminality of the ski mask, and brings them together in terms of a Romanian nationalist identity. Her staged photographs challenge preconceived notions of imagery and identity in a successful use of post-modern theory concerning appropriation of techniques of image-making, and are refreshingly shocking in their jarring representation of the human figure.

Though pleasing to look at and helpful in shaping a broader understanding of the Romanian experience, I did not find most of the paintings in this exhibition as engaging as the photography discussed above. However, the installation of 11 small paintings by Serban Savu had the opposite effect. While I was not particularly inspired by the technique used in the figurative oil paintings, the pieces did provide a commentary on the isolation of the ordinary working civilian in post-modern society. Various subjects are shown: a man sitting alone at his desk in a flourescent office, a barber cutting his client's hair while neither acknowledges the other, a group of window washers working together but not interacting. Savu's message of alienation and indifference to others in the contemporary era is conveyed clearly.


October 11, 2009

Peter Romberg



The same gallery as the Th!nk Art exhibition was also showing a series of paintings by artist Peter Romberg. The surreal and stylized representation of the body in these works reminded me a lot of the works of Lucien Freud, which we discussed in class as being morbid or unsettling. Romberg takes this artistic idea much further, painting children with various physical deformities.


The paintings often show the children from different perspectives, as though they were a scientific recording of data, rather than fine art. Romberg writes in his artist statement, "I appropriate deviations of form -revealing an affinity with the grotesque-to challenge contemporary ideals of beauty." However, he paints blocks or circles of color over the faces of the subjects. I think this prevents a challenge to contemporary ideals of beauty, and makes the work more about the grotesque deformities in these bodies. The textbook-like repetition of forms and the covered faces prevent the viewer from feeling sympathy for these children, or even seeing them as individuals. That said, the painterly style juxtaposed with this cold presentation makes for intriguing art. Perhaps choosing them as subjects for a painting, rather than photography or film, is how he challenges ideas about beauty in the context of this artistic medium. I would be interested to hear others' opinions on his work.

September 30, 2009

In My Humble Opinion...

Critique 1: Th!nkArt Group Exhibition at Bert Green Fine Art

Bert Green Fine Art is located on W. 5th in Downtown Los Angeles. Though a few blocks are designated in this area as "Gallery Row", I found little in these galleries that undertook the issues of conceptualism or post-modernism we have discussed in class. At the BGFA gallery however, I saw many works that not only showed a new perspective on the theories of image-making ArtH385 investigates, but were also varied widely enough to give an idea of different strategies utilized by contemporary artists to engage with these ideas critically. Here is my critique:

Th!nkArt is a Chicago-based gallery that curated this exhibition of contemporary French artists. Though their blurb touts that all the artists are dealing with expressing an "existential angst" inherent in French culture, the works that engaged with critical ideas by representing or deconstructing the human figure were more successful than some others in conveying their specific point of view on that subject.

The works of Michel Haas and Atonio Segui seemed to speak to this existentialist crisis in their extreme paring down of the human figure. Haas' work shows blurry and gestural shadows of figures in black and white. Segui's prints outline the figure like a caricature, with a thick, wobbly black line indicating the form. Haas reminds me of the post-war European expressionists, like sculptor Giacommetti, who expressed an angst and desperation in their depictions of the human figure. Segui's work is less evocative, and I thought his most powerful print was one that depicted a raised fist, though perhaps it is the imagery that is compelling and not the strategies used to create it


Florent Moutti's striking portraits utilize an avant-garde strategy of juxtaposition to question the identity politics of modern-day France. "Classic" French culture is signified by the beautifully painted Victorian-era wallpaper superimposed on candid depictions of individuals of different racial backgrounds whose gazes confront the viewer. In the context of our class discussion, this is an instance where the return to painting enhances the message of the work, where the brushwork is gestural and expressive as a means to and end. In the painting shown here, the figure is not fully filled in, and her outline, skin, and colors on her shirt blend together with the wallpaper, creating a singular, merged image that speaks volumes about the issue of race in a discussion of French nationalist identity.

A series of works on paper that displayed the figure in a multitude of techniques, each enhanced by the media and means of creation, was also compelling. Herve di Rosa, famous in France for his brightly colored paintings that led the "Figuration Libre" movement, showed two whimsical etchings. The two works chosen for this exhibition both seem to express something strange and alien about modern society, the first (shown here) by presenting a distorted and strange human figure, and the other by juxtaposing a childlike drawing of children on an idyllic hillside with a large spaceship that dominates the red sky. His work could be described as kitschy or cartoon-ish, and seems to be influenced by graffiti and folk art. Certainly infused with humor, these prints reminded me of Philip Guston's work in it's appropriation of the Neo-pop idiom. The similarity lies in the attempt to elevate forms of art that would not typically fit into the elitist modernist paradigm of "high art". Basquiat used similar strategies in his use of the visual language of street art. Herve di Rosa's work is more childlike than those works, and reminds me of Chicano artists such as Frank Romero who painted street murals in the 70's. It is interesting to see this folky quality in his work, seeing as he lives and works in Paris.

Though he also showed two lovely abstracted prints of flowers that mimicked photographic representation while maintaining a gestural quality exemplifying the printmaking process (much in the vein of Gerard Richter's paintings that investigated modes of image-making), the prints by Todd Narbey titled "Global Privacy I and II" were two of my favorite pieces. The starkly simple compositions show women dressed in the traditional Japanese kimono on top, and brightly colored leggings and high heels on the bottom, in blatantly pornographic poses. The titles, along with the somewhat shocking and in-your-face imagery suggests a message about the overexposure of private life in modern-day society, wherein "privacy" is non-existent. The prescense of a satellite in one of the prints reinforces this idea, as an image that evokes ideas of surveillance and the public sphere. It is interesting that the artist does not depict the female genitalia but instead leaves a conspicuous hole where it should be, letting the paper show through. It could be said that this is a strategy to convey a sense of the emptiness of such pornographic overexposure. The technique used to make the prints "gravure" has been co-opted as a term for Japanese models that appear in men's magazines and often sell fetish DVDs, which may explain the use of Japanese imagery in this artist's work. The technique lends a cut-and-paste feel to the images which makes the figures look like paper dolls, and also is reminiscent of collage techniques of the political avant-garde. Overall, these prints are a clever and multi-layered commentary on the lack of privacy and modesty in modern society.




September 25, 2009

The Continued Failure of the Avant-Garde


In our lectures regarding video and performance art of the 1970's, I found myself often rolling my eyes or suppressing a giggle. What is it about this radical and innovative art that, in the modern age, makes it seem so cliche?

As the strategies of the avant-garde become commonplace, later generations will no longer recognize the art as shocking or relevant to contemporary issues.
I believe certain institutions and cultural machines are at work here.
Take the Dada movement for example: Dada was meant to destroy art once and for all. Dadaist artists defined themselves as vehemently anti-art. Thus, when galleries and museums sanctioned Dada as an important and successful art, the movement lost it's raison d'etre. Marcel Duchamp, the father of Conceptual art, who intended to upend the institution of the gallery and destroy the authority of the museum, was recently remembered at an exhibition at our very own Norton Simon Museum in Pasadena.

Similarly, video and performance art from the 70's has been subsumed into the art historical pedagogy and museum-ified. In her discussion of video art, Martha Rosler uses John Cage as an example to speak about the failure of this art in it's attempt to rebel from the Modernist paradigm of acceptable artistic practices, "As Kaprow complained, this idea was so powerful that soon he could observe that "non-art is more art that ART-art". Meaning that this supposedly challenging counterartistic practice, this anti-aesthetic, this noninstitutionalizable form of "perceptual consciousness," was quickly an oppressively institutionalized, gobbled up by the ravenous institutions of official art (Art)."

As the innovative conceptions from the 70's have been OK'd, so to speak, by art critics and historians, we no longer find them shocking. In fact, if one thinks to call my generation apathetic, perhaps it is because all of our counter-cultural forms are subsumed by the mainstream, whether through the institution of the museum in art, or through commercialization in our commodity culture... so little seems outside the realm of acceptability. Nothing shocks us anymore, and the practices of the 1970's artists who were just discovering ways to expose the cultural mechanisms and ideologies that controlled their society seem quaint to us. In 2009, I know we live in a patriarchal culture, that my TV controls me, that a small percent of wealthy people rule the world, and that the institution of art is governed by politics as much as any other business. Somehow, since 1970, the "Down with the Man" mentality has been lost, and the practices of these artists seem outdated.


For these reasons I found the "Return to Painting in the 1980's" lecture very refreshing. Despite the male European artists making a buck in the Reagan economy, there is something to be said for the artists like George Baselitz and Philip Guston who use the creative medium of painting, to critique the institutions of art. I think their strategies resonate more with the modern viewer in the sense that they do bring the pleasure and creativity back into art, as Barbara Rose points out, and they do so while still maintaining a critical point of view and retaining a sense of the history of their craft. Personally, I think Gerhard Richter's paintings make an extremely effective critical point about modes of representation, and I would much rather see an exhibition of his than watch Chris Burden be nailed to a VW or listen to Vito Acconci masturbate beneath the floorboards.

Images from Top to Bottom, 1. Joseph Beuys, I Like America and America Likes Me, 1974 (http://www.hawaii.edu/lruby/art400/ILIKEAM.GIF), 2. Carolee Schneeman, Interior Scroll,
1975 (www.brooklynmuseum.org/.../Interior_Scroll), 3. Georg Baselitz, Akt Elke 2, 1976 (www.albrightknox.org/acquisitions/acq_2001/Baselitz.html), 4. Gerhard Richter, Confrontation 1, 1988 (www.tate.org.uk/images/cms/12518w_emblemearthly_confrontation1.jpg).